This holiday season marks the first time that easy-to-use AI shopping agents are widely available to the public. According to Gina Logan, a retail analyst with Kantar, two thirds of shoppers use AI at least occasionally for shopping tasks, but more than half still prefer to make their own purchasing decisions. Bain & Co. found that AI bots represented less than 1% of all retailer web traffic in a recent analysis of Similarweb data, a figure mirrored by streetwear retailer All Star Elite. Head of growth Abhishek Bora reported that about 1% of the company’s website visits came from agents like Muse, and on average such traffic results in just one or two purchases per week. For retailers, catering to this new type of customer has meant updating websites with machine-readable data layers to help bots find and interpret products and promotions.
Despite the modest numbers, AI agents appear to be more effective at converting searches into purchases than traditional web search, the Bain report concluded. Consumers already utilizing agentic shopping skew younger, wealthier, and more tech savvy, according to a Zappi survey. Steve Phillips, founder and chief innovation officer at Zappi, compared today’s AI shopping habits to the early days of internet travel booking when users would research hotels online but still phone in their reservations. “There is a massive trust factor there,” said Phillips.
For many, the main value of AI agents is streamlining product discovery and offering options from lesser-known brands. Amrita Bhasin, co-founder and CEO of sustainable supply chain startup Sotira, uses ChatGPT and Google’s Gemini to identify potential purchases, though she still prefers to finalize transactions herself. “Figuring out what to buy is where I face severe decision fatigue,” she said, but noted reservations over an agent making a purchasing error on her behalf.
Some retailers, like Walmart, are leaning in by introducing tools that make agentic shopping easier, while Amazon is instead directing shoppers to use Alexa and blocking third-party bots. For other companies, AI strategy remains focused on enhancing customer experience, executives at Target and Home Depot told Business Insider.
Still, incorporating AI into the highly personal ritual of gift giving remains fraught. While bots may excel at finding deals, selecting the perfect present for a loved one is a nuanced, emotional process that many consumers are reluctant to fully outsource. Mandelos, reflecting on his own experience, suggested that thoughtfully prompting the AI could become a “21st-century love language” in itself. For now, both shoppers and retailers are testing the limits of how far AI can go in the festive holiday marketplace.
